‘Expected Passing %’: between accuracy and difficulty

Category: Player Analysis

How complicated is the pass I just saw on television? It is a question as simple as it is complex. With your powers of analysis and perception you may conclude that it is easy or difficult, or you may put an adverb in front of it to add some degree of difficulty or ease, but […]


How complicated is the pass I just saw on television? It is a question as simple as it is complex. With your powers of analysis and perception you may conclude that it is easy or difficult, or you may put an adverb in front of it to add some degree of difficulty or ease, but you can’t go too deep. There may be difficult passes that, with data in hand, become a real rarity that no one in a particular championship has been able to replicate.

One of the tasks and fundamentals of advanced statistics is to develop predictive and probability models that help to more deeply and accurately measure a concept or parameter of the game. In the case of passing, counting the percentage of successful passes or the percentage of long passes is fine, but we are a long way from measuring the true value that a player brings with his intentions, risks and successes. To begin to tell the story of how our Expected Passing % model is shaped, we will consider the following.

First, we collect basic geometric information about the pass and its location:

  • X-coordinate of the start location of the pass.
  • Y-coordinate reflected at the start location of the pass
  • Angle of the pass based on the end location
  • Approximate distance of the pass based on the final location

Next, we take into account whether:

  • The pass was made with the feet or with the head.
  • It was a pass in play, a set piece, a goal kick or a cross.

With this model and to understand and visualise the data, as with the Expected Goals model, we calculate the probability of a pass being successful, with 0 being a failed pass and 1 being a successful pass. If the model gives a value of 0.37 xP, then the pass had a 37% chance of being completed. Another way to read the metric is that if a pass had 0.10 xP then only 1 in 10 of that type of pass was completed. Let’s use a graphical example to support the idea.

This map below is interactive. It corresponds to Barcelona’s 1-0 win over Atletico Madrid on matchday 30 of the 2022/23 Spanish league championship. If you hover your mouse over each circle, you will get more information about who made the pass. The play unfolds quickly: three passes are executed and a shot, by Ferran Torres, leads to the only goal of the match.

To see the play, in this Youtube link, from second 51, you can see the three passes and their level of difficulty, which we will then transfer to their corresponding value within the Expected Passes model. Taking into account the variables we described at the beginning of the text, each pass is given a value of probability of success.

The pass from Koundé to Araujo, with 0.92 (92% probability of completion).
Araujo’s pass to Raphinha, with 0.26 xP (26% probability).
And finally, the one from Raphinha to Ferran, with 0.78 (78% probability).

The metric contains the value of being able to know which players make passes of a higher or lower probability, thus relating the risk they take to their position, area of the pitch or daring to add value. For this reason, it is especially useful to extract the average for each player over the course of a competition to know, as in the Expected Goals per Shot metric, the average value of all passes made by the player. Here you will see that centre-backs, full-backs or midfielders have a very different average value.

An interesting way to visualise who completes more passes than expected and how difficult, on average, the passes they make are, is with the following table. In it we see the best midfielders in Spanish La Liga 22/23, all belonging to Real Madrid, in the differential between expected passes and completed passes, both expressed as a percentage. If the most effective strikers have a very positive differential between goals and expected goals, the most accurate midfielders also have a very positive differential between passes completed and expected passes.

We are Driblab, a consultancy specialized in the statistical analysis of players and teams; our work is focused on advising and minimizing risk in professional football decision-making in areas related to talent detection and footballer evaluations. Our database has more than 200,000 players from more than 180 competitions, covering information from all over the world. Here you can learn more about how we work and what we offer.

Autor: Alejandro Arroyo
For Player Analysis we also recommend you:

Who are the Best Pressing Players in the Most Intense League?

Who presses more effectively in the Bundesliga 23/24?

How good is the forward I’m looking for at pressing and defending?

We explain how we can model our data and visualizations to understand how much and with what success the center forward we are looking for defends and works off the ball.

Joao Neves: the data makes clear his incredible impact

What does the data say about one of the most surprising midfielders of the moment? Perhaps a lot more than you expect.

‘xG Build up 5 passes’: adjusting (further) the value of players in each possession

We discover the best midfielders in possessions that generate ‘expected goals’ by measuring only the five passes prior to the last pass.

Endrick 2024: understanding his near future with data

We analyse Endrick’s rapid evolution: new areas of the field, new roles and new plays. Endrick 2024 is starting to come into view.

Expected threat open play ‘in team’: the truly irreplaceable players

We highlight the top 20 players who are most indispensable to their teams in generating danger.

Ranking defensively compromised wingers

We discovered the wingers who complete the most defensive actions and show the most commitment defending in their own half.

Passing and carrying: who makes the most progress with the ball?

Through two metrics of ball progression, we discover the midfielders who most often progress possession with a pass or a carry.

ON/OFF: a big warning for the European champions

We used our ON/OFF tool to analyse, across 14 metrics, the impact Rodri’s absence is having on Manchester City’s play.

The Victor Boniface moment

Victor Boniface has started the season finishing five times per 90′ than last season, increasing the records of the best Cristiano Ronaldo.


Información corporativa

Somos una empresa con sede en Madrid fundada en 2017 por Salvador Carmona y Cristian Coré Ramiro. Desde nuestros inicios nuestro trabajo se ha centrado en el análisis estadístico de datos para ayudar a los clubes en la planificación deportiva. Somos una consultora big data que ofrece servicios personalizados para cada cliente y defiende un modelo de gestión mixto y una comunicación constante para acompañar el día a día de las instituciones. Nuestro punto fuerte es la más amplia cobertura disponible en número de torneos profesionales y juveniles. Para más detalles, póngase en contacto con nosotros.

Colaboramos con:


Hemos aparecido en: